Sign Up |  Login

     
 
    My Blog |  Popular Posts |  Top 100 Blogs |  Recent Blogs |  Random Blogs |  Write a Blog |  Manage Categories |  New Members |  Comments  
   View Blog
 
 exercise does not make you thin
Well, as I was online surfing for great deals on used Stairmasters (a gal can dream) I came across an article that intrigued me, because its sentiment and conclusion seemed to support something I'd asserted for years but also found a bit baffling...exercise has never once made me thin. No matter how much I do, no matter how insanely hard I train. There were long stretches in my life where I'd hop onto a treadmill and run throughout the entire duration of a movie, a long one like The Abyss (lol), and do it 5 days per week, sometimes 6 days, and I was at my heaviest and largest size ever then.  How could I run for almost 2 hours per day and not lose a damn ounce?

Scientists would say that it's more about what you're eating than how much you exercise. Of course, this isn't to say exercise should be dropped, not at all.  But strapping oneself to a machine or becoming a gym rat in the hopes of obtaining that coveted size 4 is a futile endeavor in and of itself.  Exercise will certainly boost your energy, when done properly and safely, and will obviously give you better overall strength and endurance.  On a psychological level it boosts self esteem, but as the article touches upon briefly, THAT is a cultural phenomenon it seems, and they cite the French paradox to support that claim.  The French seem to enjoy lives of rich food, daily wine, sometimes with each meal, and they do NOT chain themselves to treadmills or Stairmasters and yet the overall health and size of the nation is quite admirable.  It's always baffled scientists, but it seems that some of it should be obvious.

First, while they do eat rich foods loaded with butter and cream and all sorts of yummy things we Americans view as "treats" or outright taboo, they eat very small portions.  Second, the act of eating is a whole other experience for the French...they sit, they talk, they sip magnificent wine, they savor, and they allow a meal of small portioned rich food to take quite a while...eating slowly is an art, a joy and not only allows the brain time to receive those chemical signals that the body is satisfied, but it tends to accompany proper digestion.  And looking at the emotional component, a decadent souffle eaten slowly with wine while conversing and laughing with friends and family brings pure joy without a shred of guilt. The French do not generally sit and think, as they sip their pinot noir, that they will have to run a few extra miles the next say. Sacre bleu! LOL  No, they enjoy every morsel, every nuance of flavor and every long moment of a decadent meal...hence, the food and wine become elixirs of joy and life, not burdens.

What I can personally attest to as an American with a lifelong and horrible connection to both food and my own body, which I am working on every day of my life consciously, is that no amount of exercise has ever or will ever make me thin. The times in my life when I have been at my leanest and smallest in size have been when I was both eating the best way for me, which tends to be little to no sugars or starches and properly combined food sans wheat, dairy, soy or meat...AND when I've been incredibly happy and in love. No mystery there, but growing up I was fed the fitness craze myth that if you worked out hard enough, long enough and often enough you could whittle away pound after pound...and I have never found that to be so.  Certainly when I'd find myself shedding weight and toxins by eating well and opening the heart to love that would usually prompt me to WANT to move more and gather even more energy through exercise, and then it becomes a joy, like recess for grown ups rather than penance.  But when I'd share these experiences and views with people I'd get arguments, defenses and puzzled looks.  They'd assure me I was either eating too much or exercising too little...it was neither. During those crazy long runs I'd be eating about 1200 calories per day, so mathematically speaking I should have been dropping pounds like mad.  Sure, the metabolism slows down when you starve, I know, but it also should rev up from running for 2 hours per day.  But it's WHAT I was eating and how I was feeling that was keeping the weight on.

And now here I see a twenty year study essentially confirming what I'd already learned by my own experience...exercise will never make me thin.  Only eating in a way that's healthy and right for me and truly being a happy gal can I have the light, supple, youthful and energetic body I love to have and BE.

I also realized that when I was a young child, traveling quite a bit with my mother and living abroad for part of that time, I never gave a moment's thought to my body or what I ate...we ate very healthy, very well and I was incredibly active...a fit and glowing child.  But within coming back to the U.S. and being exposed to TV and media, being conditioned to hate my body and believe I should look a certain way while simultaneously being sold the standard american diet of pure crap...well, is it any wonder a lifelong cycle of confusion and eating disorders had begun in full swing by the time I was 7 years old? Sad, but true.

So cast off the guilt and the conditioned beliefs that a) your body is ugly or wrong, b) that you can lose weight by "going for the burn" and working your tookus off on a machine and c) that the act of eating needs to be complicated and about deprivation.  Stop shoveling food in mindlessly and eating processed crap...eat slowly, with joy and presence and reverence...laugh and smile and be amongst people you admire and adore while you eat...move your body out of joy and a desire to connect to MORE energy and more radiance...bask in the beauty of YOU, as you are, right this very moment...close your eyes, even if only for 60 seconds at your computer, and honestly radiate love to yourself, from yourself...even say it out loud, softly if you feel silly, but say it until you feel it and MEAN it.

Self love, joy, peace, presence and celebrating life with every single sip of wine or bite of a rich, lovely dish...doesn't that sound so much more appealing and meaningful than the way we're doing it now.  Time to stop ice skating uphill, methinks. ;)

(ah, here's a link to the New York Magazine article I came across today as well:
http://nymag.com/news/sports/38001/)
    Posted by marathongal on 2009-06-17 13:04:32 | Rating: | Views: 146
    Email This to a Friend            Print This Blog Post  

  Bookmark:
Permalink:  
   Blog Comments
  
i think its all about an equal balance of working out and eating healthy, i personally eat pretty healthy, not that i put too much thought into it, i just try to eat from all the food groups on a daylie basis and it usually works out pretty well for me.

ive noticed that if i do that and go to the gym 2 or 3 times a week i may gain weight (muscle weighs more than fat) but i deffinetly tone my body and have lost inches!!
Posted by  heart189  on 2009-06-17 13:19:21 
  
According to the study conducted, even runners who logged incredible miles were still gaining weight, and they were eating what would be considered "healthy" foods, but the constant exercise wasn't doing anything to keep them from gaining or to even lose prior weight.

Certainly to tone muscle and give your body more overall strength you want to engage in exercise, but for the millions who beat themselves up with caloric restriction and torturous hours at the gym...not a means to the desired ends.
Posted by  marathongal  on 2009-06-17 13:26:06 
  
Mara',

Ask a boxer how to lose and gain weight, in conjunction with exercise, often times boxer's weight fluxuates in order to fight in different weight classes, while maintaining a strict regimine of exercise; they do not lose muscle mass, only fat, and they are healthy doing it.

They focus on their intake of carbohydrates, fluids, protiens, and the different foods that will cause them to lose or gain weight.

Naturally, if you burn more calories than you take in, you WILL lose weight, without question.

- Thom

PS - I love the profile pic - Is that your hair? - It's angelic! ... beautiful!

Posted by  Hugh_Pizmehoff  on 2009-06-17 14:45:58 
  
Well, my point and the point of the study I came across is that it is not necessarily true that if you burn more than you take in, you'll lose weight. My case is a good example of that, and I have another friend who's had the same conundrum for years...I'd be easily burning more calories per day than I was taking in for 3 months or more, by a long shot, but I was my heaeviest and not an inch or a pound came off. I increased strength, my endurance was great, but I was still fat.

When I changed WHAT I was eating (which for me meant not even fruit sugar, no wheat, no dairy, no soy, etc)I could eat FAR more food, do less exercise or even skipped it a few days per week and 40 pounds dropped off as easy as you please. That was when I did a thorough Candida cleanse program.

oh, the profile pic is not me, I prefer to keep a bit more anonymous, but I do have long henna red hair....just more fiery than that. ;) I love the pic though, the Caribbean blues contrasting with the titian hair...so gorgeous!

btw, boxers have one of the most amazing training regimes you will EVER see. their strength, stamina and agilty are nothing short of breathtaking.
Posted by  marathongal  on 2009-06-17 15:21:29 
  
I love this, and I agree with it entirely. I ran 30-50 miles a week for years and my weight never dropped or changed whatsoever. It's food that changes my body. Running/exercise does give me more energy and great muscle tone, but definitely does not make me thinner. This whole conundrum is partially why shows like the Biggest Loser baffle me...

When I became vegetarian I instantly dropped 15 pounds in about 2 months. I had been running my regular regime before that and when I took the meat out of my diet it was just that simple, boom. Poundage was gone and I FELT lighter. I felt excellent. When I adjusted to more of a raw foods diet, my pants fit looser. It just makes perfect sense.

One thing not mentioned about the French Paradox, they DO walk pretty much everywhere they go, that is also something we Americans do not do. Keeping generally more active, I believe, helps you pay better attention to what you're putting into your body. But the way we go about "keeping active" is just all wrong and out there.
Posted by  VegRunner  on 2009-06-17 18:28:13 
  
Couldn't agree more about walking, although in Chitown I walked everywhere until I was about 24 and got my license...I used to log probably 3 miles per day minimum, cause I walked to and from school, work, friends, etc...kept me vital and energetic but I was still a porker til I got the food thing.

STILL, I agree that an organically active life is a key missing element here in the land of the free, home of the Whopper. ;)
Posted by  marathongal  on 2009-06-17 21:11:48 
Would you like to comment?

    (Maximum characters: 5000)
    You have characters left.
  Blog Information
 

marathongal
California ( Southern), United States

Latest Posts

 reconnecting
 Blade Runner, why I...
 living asthanga...
 practice...and all is...
 the yin and the yang...

marathongal's Links

 No links found

Blog Categories

 Nothing found

Blog Archive

 September 2009 (3)
 August 2009 (6)
 July 2009 (3)
 June 2009 (1)
 May 2009 (8)
 April 2009 (11)
 March 2009 (15)
 February 2009 (2)
 January 2009 (3)
 December 2008 (3)
 November 2008 (1)
 October 2008 (14)
 September 2008 (15)
 August 2008 (24)
 July 2008 (17)
 June 2008 (18)
 November 2007 (16)
 October 2007 (3)

Comment Archives

 September 2009 (1)
 August 2009 (1)
 June 2009 (3)
 May 2009 (7)
 April 2009 (10)
 March 2009 (23)
 February 2009 (1)
 January 2009 (2)
 December 2008 (5)
 October 2008 (10)
 September 2008 (7)
 August 2008 (4)
 July 2008 (1)
 June 2008 (5)
 November 2007 (4)

Page load time: 0.49875402450562 ms